Biscayne 21's Holdouts Got Paid. What Edgewater Condo Buyers Should Take From It

October 8, 2026
Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?
A limestone-floored condo living room with a teak lounge chair and closed sliding glass doors overlooking a concrete terrace and a potted sea grape tree.

"This was not a sick building. They had just put $6 million into it." Glen Waldman of Armstrong Teasdale represented the holdout owners at Biscayne 21, the bayfront building at 2121 North Bayshore Drive in Edgewater. He said this in early September 2026, days after his clients settled with Two Roads Development for about $50 million combined.

Most coverage tells this as a fight between a developer and a few stubborn neighbors. For someone weighing an older Edgewater condo against a new tower, it reads more usefully as a pricing lesson. An older unit on the bay is two assets at once. One is the apartment. The other is a small share of a waterfront site a developer may someday want. The building's declaration of condominium decides how much of that second asset any single owner controls, and that document often dates back half a century.

The clause that set the price

Biscayne 21 recorded its declaration on December 10, 1974. That document required "the unanimous agreement of the Unit Owners" to terminate the condominium. A separate amendment clause required 100% owner approval for any change to owners' voting rights.

In May 2022, Two Roads began buying units in bulk. With the votes from those units, it took over the board. In August 2022, the new board replaced the unanimity requirement with the 80% threshold in current Florida law, and in September it approved a plan of termination over the holdouts' objections.

The Third District Court of Appeal held that lowering the termination threshold from 100% to 80% altered owners' voting rights. Under this declaration, that change needed every owner's consent. The court also found that the original language submitting the building to the Condominium Act "as amended" did not automatically import the newer 80% rule. The court relied on a 2016 Tropicana decision, which said a non-unanimous amendment cannot "eviscerate" veto rights that owners hold by contract. The Florida Supreme Court declined review on October 14, 2025.

The full value of each holdout's veto came from a clause written in 1974. A unit with the same view in a building whose declaration simply follows the statute would not have carried it.

What the veto was worth

The numbers show the gap. In 2022, Two Roads paid about $150 million for the majority of Biscayne 21's 192 units. Spread across all 192 units, $150 million works out to about $781,000 each. Two Roads bought fewer than all of them, so its real average was higher, but in the same range. The holdouts' settlement came to about $6.3 million per owner, according to The Real Deal's estimate, which counts each of the two couples as one owner.

Most of that gap came from time. One holdout told The Real Deal that Two Roads offered him nearly $1.3 million for his unit in early 2021. The holdout asked for about a third more, enough to cover renovation and replacement costs. By the holdout's account, paying the holdout and a neighbor a combined $600,000 to $700,000 above the bulk price "could have avoided everything that happened." The holdouts sued in May 2023, and there was no response to that request first. The building's air conditioning failed that summer, and the building was later declared uninhabitable. The holdouts lost access to their units in 2023.

That point matters as much as the payout. The veto paid off only after about three years without use of the homes, while the case went from trial court to appeal and on to the Florida Supreme Court. One holdout described the developer's costs as "many tens of millions in interest, penalties, loan extensions." The holdout side bore costs as well. Taylor Collins of Two Roads called the process "very emotional for both sides."

The statute protects owners at a different stage

Under current Florida law, a buyer can't expect the statute alone to deliver the protection the Biscayne 21 declaration provided. Section 718.117(3) of the 2026 Florida Statutes allows optional termination with approval from at least 80% of all voting interests. A plan cannot proceed if 5% or more reject it, and a rejection bars another plan for 24 months. In a 192-unit building, 5% is about 10 units. That is roughly the size of the Biscayne 21 holdout group, which was ten unit owners.

The statute's financial protections apply only when a single bulk owner holds at least 80% of the voting interests at the time the plan is recorded. In that case:

  • Every owner other than the bulk owner must receive at least 100% of fair market value, set by an independent appraiser no earlier than 90 days before recording.
  • A homestead-exempt owner who is current on both assessments and other monetary obligations to the association receives at least the original purchase price paid for the unit.
  • Homestead owners also receive a relocation payment equal to 1% of their allocated proceeds.
  • Owners in occupancy may request a 12-month lease if the former units are offered for rent.
  • Before owners consider the plan, a sworn statement must disclose each unit the bulk owner acquired and what it paid.

Those floors protect owners who are still in the building when the plan is recorded. Owners who sell to an assembler earlier, while a buyer is still working toward 80%, are making a private sale at whatever price they negotiate. The disclosure rule means the remaining owners will eventually see those prices. The statute was last amended in 2025, and the version posted for 2026 still contains these provisions.

The same math is playing out around Edgewater

Biscayne 21 is the only Edgewater building buyout that our research found in 2025 or 2026. The pattern around it is broader, and the per-unit prices give a sense of what developers are paying for older buildings across the county.

Building Area Reported deal Approx. per unit Status
Bayshore Park, 2545 S. Bayshore Dr. Coconut Grove 39 units, about $28M $718,000 Full ownership by March 2026; termination and redevelopment planned
Virginia Pointe, 3245 Virginia St. Coconut Grove 59 of 66 units, $27.7M $470,000 Majority bought March 2026; rentals planned
Mariners Bay, 12000 N. Bayshore Dr. North Miami 46 units, $48.5M $1.05M Closed 2025; replacement tower planned
Miami Beach Club, 19051 Collins Ave. Sunny Isles Beach Remaining 100 units, $131.8M $1.32M Closed 2025; new tower planned
St. Louis, 800 Claughton Island Dr. Brickell Key 134 units, about $200M discussed About $1.5M In negotiation as of April 2026

The per-unit figures are simple averages from the reported totals. Actual payments to individual owners vary by unit.

For comparison, the median existing-condo sale across Miami-Dade in August 2026 was $408,000. Condos took about 108 days to sell, and the county had 12.1 months of supply, according to Miami Realtors. Those figures cover the whole county, not Edgewater. They do show why bulk offers stand out in a resale market that is moving slowly. In the deals above where developers plan new towers, they have been paying for waterfront land, and each unit's price reflects that.

The threshold question is still being tested. At the Amethyst at 5313 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach, Mast Capital had acquired 35 of 120 units by March 2026. An owner there sued over an amendment that lowered the termination threshold.

What happens at 2121 North Bayshore next

Two Roads plans to build Edition Residences on the site. The first tower is planned at 55 stories and 185 units, with prices that started at $1.7 million when sales launched in 2022. The Miami Herald reported on September 2, 2026 that Two Roads expected to start construction that month and finish in September 2029. As of early September, the settlement still needed court sign-off and the deeds had not been recorded. A separate suit from three buyers seeking about $2.5 million in Edition deposits was still pending at that point. All of these timelines are the developer's targets, not confirmed milestones.

Collins has asked the Legislature for "a clear, fair and predictable process for terminating condominium associations." For now, the rules are the 2026 statute plus whatever each building's declaration says.

Reading an older Edgewater building before you make an offer

For buyers considering an older bayfront building, these questions about the condo documents come before the view:

  1. What termination threshold does the declaration state? Some older declarations still say unanimity, as Biscayne 21's did. Others follow the statute's 80%.
  2. What does the amendment clause require for changes to voting rights? At Biscayne 21, that clause decided the case.
  3. Does the declaration adopt the Condominium Act "as amended and/or renumbered from time to time," or does it lock in the law as of its recording date? The court treated the general phrase "as amended" as not enough to import the newer rule automatically.
  4. Has the board amended the declaration recently, and who controls the board? At Biscayne 21, the amendments came after a bulk buyer gained control of the board.
  5. Do association records show any single owner building up a large block of units? If a bulk owner reaches 80% and proposes termination, the statute requires a sworn statement identifying anyone who owns or controls 25% or more of the units, along with every unit the bulk owner acquired and what it paid.

This is general information, not legal advice. A Florida real estate attorney should review the declaration and amendments for any specific building.

FAQ

Does Biscayne 21's outcome mean every older Edgewater condo has a veto? No. The ruling turned on that building's 1974 declaration, which required unanimity and protected voting rights from amendment without 100% consent. A declaration written differently could produce a different result.

If a developer reaches 80%, what is the minimum the remaining owners receive? Under 718.117(3), owners other than the bulk owner receive at least 100% of independently appraised fair market value. A homestead owner who is current on both assessments and other monetary obligations to the association receives at least the original purchase price, plus a 1% relocation payment.

Were other Edgewater buildings bought out in 2025 or 2026? Our research found no other reported Edgewater building buyout in that period. The comparable deals were in Coconut Grove, North Miami, Sunny Isles Beach and Brickell Key.

Before you make an offer on an older Edgewater building, CASA Collection Group will review the declaration's termination and amendment clauses, any recent amendments, and the building's ownership records with you and your attorney. Schedule a free consultation.

Marco Tiné

About the Author

Marco Tiné is a Miami Beach real estate professional dedicated to creating seamless, rewarding experiences for his clients, whether buying, selling, or renting. A full-time agent since 2014, Marco holds the prestigious Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS) designation with Guild™ recognition and is consistently recognized for his outstanding sales performance. Known for his meticulous attention to detail, deep knowledge of the Miami market, and warm, approachable nature, Marco blends professionalism with genuine care. With Venezuelan and Sicilian roots and a passion for philanthropy, fitness, and family, he brings authenticity and dedication to every client relationship.

📍 1688 Meridian Ave, #700, Miami Beach, FL 33139
📞 (786) 797-8463

Buy

Browse exclusive properties in the area.

Browse Homes

Sell

Find out what your home is really worth.

Get a Quote

Let's Work Together

Marco Tiné delivers exceptional services tailored to both home buyers and sellers. His in-depth knowledge of the Miami, FL market ensures a seamless and successful transaction. Ready to elevate your real estate journey? Contact him today.